Penny Timothy

Residential Sales

M: 0418 546 500

P: 02 8356 2700

E: ptimothy@rwebay.com.au


Penny Timothy has a well-deserved reputation as one of the leading agents in Elizabeth Bay / Potts Point. Penny has an in depth knowledge of the local area and an innovative, businesslike approach to marketing.

The results can be seen in Penny's record-breaking sales across the spectrum of property styles in this eclectic village, including multi-million dollar terraces and whole floor apartments. Penny understands the needs of owner-occupiers and investors alike. Penny has a unique combination of dedication and professionalism, combined with a gift for identifying the potential in every client’s property.

As a resident owner, Penny has served as both Treasurer on a Strata Body Corporate in Potts Point and as a Company Title Board Member in Elizabeth Bay.

Property is Penny’s great passion and on a personal level she has renovated and sold several homes and is an active participant in the running of the Art Deco building where she lives in the heart of Elizabeth Bay.

"Penny Timothy recently sold our apartment in Potts Point. I would recommend her without reservation. Her judgment is absolutely sound. She is professional, warm committed, hard-working and, above all, intelligent. She knows the local property market intimately. The advice she gave us – from the renovations planned for the apartment to the ultimate sales campaign – was spot on and contributed in no small measure to the highly impressive price we received at auction. From the first moment I met her, she was an absolute pleasure to deal with, imbuing us with confidence and making the whole process of selling our property easy, uncomplicated and stress-free."

- Lucy Robb

"Dear Penny,

I write to thank you for your utter professionalism and charming grace throughout the sale process of our two Sydney apartments in Elizabeth Bay. Living interstate might have presented difficulties but the presentation of the apartments in our absence showed an excellent understanding of what was attractive to potential buyers. The photographs looked so good, we were tempted to buy ourselves!

Your immediate understanding of our interests and of the wider residential market gave us great confidence to proceed with the sale process. On the way through this process, we greatly appreciated your regular written and telephone updates on the views of prospective buyers and the response to open days that kept us in touch with the market and gave us an accurate and realistic assessment of the likely selling prices.

I am very sorry that we were not able to be there in Sydney on the night of the auction because of prior commitments in Melbourne, but we felt absolutely confident to be on the telephone with you during the auction. The final result was very pleasing.

Thank you again for handling this whole process so well. We don’t have any more property in Sydney to sell, but if we did, we would be delighted to use your excellent services again. We would certainly recommend you to others were we to be asked to name a great agent in Sydney’s Eastern suburbs."

- Carrillo Gantner AO

"We recently sold an apartment in Elizabeth Bay with Penny Timothy as our agent. The whole process was made easy and pleasant by Penny’s detailed experience, knowledge of the area and of the building itself, her effortless competence and pleasant manner. All communication was spot on, quick and nothing was too much trouble. All in all, I can think of no way that the experience could have been improved. If I had any more property business in the area, I would ask for her to handle it."

- Chris & Michelle Hulley

"I arrived in Sydney to sort out a two storey apartment which belonged to an elderly friend in Melbourne who was going into a nursing home. The house was piled high with possessions and unused for years. We set about cleaning it up and I rang Penny, and after an initial visit I decided to look no further.

There was a lot to do up in Sydney and a lot to finish from a great distance. Penny organized tradespeople and everything went smoothly, quickly and easily, thanks entirely to Penny. The place was repaired, re-carpeted and auctioned to our great satisfaction.

I expected numerous trips back and forth but didn’t need one. Penny is the best!"

- Newton Lane

"Selling a property is a stressful process for anyone, so it is a blessing when you find an agent that works hard to reduce this pressure.

Penny’s work was professional from start to finish. She provided a very comprehensive, competitive and clear proposal that even a novice could understand. Penny then proceeded to deliver on this proposal exactly as outlined. What I appreciated the most was the clear and up-to-date communication; all delivered with a healthy dose of laughs and honesty.

The volume of potential buyers was fantastic and the leads were followed up diligently. My apartment sold for a very good price in the range that was predicted by Penny and it set a record for my building. Great service and a great result; what more could you ask for?"

- Tia Hassam

"Anthea and I first met Ms Timothy when inspecting an apartment in Birtley Towers in Elizabeth Bay; this apartment was soon to become our new home. From that moment, we were impressed with her professionalism, enthusiasm and integrity. Throughout our dealings with her, she acted with grace and great propriety.

We then asked Ms Timothy if she would be the agent to sell our terrace house in Darlinghurst, so impressed were we with her in our purchase of the apartment in Birtley Towers. In the sale of our residence, her professionalism was first class. We were very impressed with her business acumen and carry the greatest respect for the character and wisdom she displayed. We would recommend her to anyone considering a real estate venture."

- Howe & Anthea Synott

"Dear Penny,

I just want to briefly thank you for all of your efforts regarding the sale of my terrace house in Potts Point. Almost one week prior to Christmas, in a year that was widely acknowledged as being difficult for properties in the high end price bracket, your achievement of a sale is commendable. I put this down to your pro-activity, professionalism, persistence (in sourcing interest) and personable manner."

- Sam Kushe

"Penny kept me up to date with the marketing program for the sale of my property on an almost daily basis. Penny impressed with her professional competence in the area of people skills and sales, resulting in my property attracting record numbers of potential buyers during the three week campaign. As a result, the property established a new price benchmark for sales in the building.

Finally, I commend Penny to those who seek honesty and efficiency in Real Estate dealings in Elizabeth Bay and its surrounding areas."

- Robyn Paterson

"I am very grateful to the outstanding service provided by your company, especially my compliments and sincere appreciation go to Penny Timothy who handled the progress in a very professional way constantly keeping us updated on progress etc.
I can very highly recommend this company and would not hesitate doing business again in the future.
"

- Marcel Widmer

"Penny and the team at R & W Elizabeth Bay were helpful, professional and a total delight throughout the process of purchasing my place in Elizabeth Bay. Penny Timothy, in particular, helped to make the experience as stress free and straightforward as possible. "

- Sophie Bosch

"The effort undertaken by both Greg and Penny on behalf of our sale was highly professional. I could not be happier with the process and the outcome. "

- Ron Keir

Penny's Current Listings

Penny's Recent Sales

Email Agent

  • Anti-Spam Image
  • Submit